Also
Trump v. Hawaii with Trump-nominated Neil Gorsuch (not recusing).
In United States v. Nixon however "Justice William Rehnquist recused himself as he had previously served in the Nixon administration as an Assistant Attorney General". Rehnquist was also Nixon-nominated to the Supreme Court, but he didn't include in his recusal the latter reason. The same Court also had Nixon-nominated justices Harry Blackmun and Lewis F. Powell Jr. on board, neither of whom recused, and even the Chief Justice of that court, Warren Burger, had been nominated by Nixon himself.
I think the fact that there is a Senate confirmation for Supreme Justices makes the nomination remote enough not to be a reason for recusal. I'm not sure anyone has argued it explicitly along these lines though.
One pretty long review paper on recusals argues that
A more demanding recusal standard is possible at the lower federal court levels precisely because recourse is available--other judges are available to be substituted. At the Supreme Court level, however, precluding Justices from hearing cases for purely remote precautionary reasons, and thereby silencing important voices in the decision-making process, is impolitic, unwise, and counterproductive.
and
If, indeed, "the judgments that the President and the Senate are supposed to reach in the nomination and confirmation processes are essentially political judgments-in both the highest and lowest senses of that term," then Supreme Court Justices have, in fact, been selected because they hold particular biases. Having appointed a particular individual based on that person's ideology (and political connections) renders recusal due to bias as to those ideological issues incongruent.
Also
What are the consequences when a Supreme Court Justice disregards the statutory proscriptions? The Justice will not be subject to a disciplinary hearing; the only real remedy would appear to be impeachment.
Speaking of which there was at least one Supreme Justice, Abe Fortas, who resigned under threat of impeachment (during Nixon's presidency). Although Fortas was accused of some conflicts of interest, these didn't involve the president.