Skip to main content
Added more sources in response to comment
Source Link

"Any reliable indicators of the popular sentiment in Afghanistan?"

Inference based on battles aren't a reliable indicator of popular sentiment. At best, they are an indicator of the sentiment of the army personnel. A better indicator may be from afghan sources/public figures who are apolitical.

The below is from popular afghan public/sports figures who are not politically affiliated: Rashid Khan and Nabi

Rashid Khan's twitter message

"My country is in chaos,thousand of innocent people, including children & women, get martyred everyday, houses & properties being destructed.Thousand families displaced..Don’t leave us in chaos."

Mohammed Nabi's twitter messageMohammed Nabi's twitter message

"I appeal to the leaders of the world; please don't let Afghanistan go into chaos. We need your Support. We want Peace."

Conclusion:

  1. Even for people in Afghanistan, the Taliban as an unknown. They don't know what to expect, and don't want chaos.
  2. The people of afghanistan don't have a choice in whether to like Taliban on not. They've been handed over to the Taliban by their army and bad planning on governance transition after Western troop withdrawal.
  3. The popular sentiment in Kabul is that they've been let down -both by the west, and their government.

EDIT 18-08-2021: In response to a comment below, adding some more sources that perhaps reflect the popular sentiment in Afghanistan

  1. Demonstrations in Jalalabad in favour of the afghan flag
  2. Demonstations in Khost against the Taliban
  3. Flag hoisting at Nangrahar
  4. Protests and firing in Jalalabad
  5. Restoration of the afghan flag in Jalalabad
  6. Women protestors in Kabul
  7. Protests in Kunar province: rehoisting of flag and demonstrations

Some signs that behind all the PR, the Taliban are still the same

and some signs that the war is not yet fully won by the Taliban:

"Any reliable indicators of the popular sentiment in Afghanistan?"

Inference based on battles aren't a reliable indicator of popular sentiment. At best, they are an indicator of the sentiment of the army personnel. A better indicator may be from afghan sources/public figures who are apolitical.

The below is from popular afghan public/sports figures who are not politically affiliated: Rashid Khan and Nabi

Rashid Khan's twitter message

"My country is in chaos,thousand of innocent people, including children & women, get martyred everyday, houses & properties being destructed.Thousand families displaced..Don’t leave us in chaos."

Mohammed Nabi's twitter message

"I appeal to the leaders of the world; please don't let Afghanistan go into chaos. We need your Support. We want Peace."

Conclusion:

  1. Even for people in Afghanistan, the Taliban as an unknown. They don't know what to expect, and don't want chaos.
  2. The people of afghanistan don't have a choice in whether to like Taliban on not. They've been handed over to the Taliban by their army and bad planning on governance transition after Western troop withdrawal.
  3. The popular sentiment in Kabul is that they've been let down - by the west, and their government.

"Any reliable indicators of the popular sentiment in Afghanistan?"

Inference based on battles aren't a reliable indicator of popular sentiment. At best, they are an indicator of the sentiment of the army personnel. A better indicator may be from afghan sources/public figures who are apolitical.

The below is from popular afghan public/sports figures who are not politically affiliated: Rashid Khan and Nabi

Rashid Khan's twitter message

"My country is in chaos,thousand of innocent people, including children & women, get martyred everyday, houses & properties being destructed.Thousand families displaced..Don’t leave us in chaos."

Mohammed Nabi's twitter message

"I appeal to the leaders of the world; please don't let Afghanistan go into chaos. We need your Support. We want Peace."

Conclusion:

  1. Even for people in Afghanistan, the Taliban as an unknown. They don't know what to expect, and don't want chaos.
  2. The people of afghanistan don't have a choice in whether to like Taliban on not. They've been handed over to the Taliban by their army and bad planning on governance transition after Western troop withdrawal.
  3. The popular sentiment in Kabul is that they've been let down both by the west, and their government.

EDIT 18-08-2021: In response to a comment below, adding some more sources that perhaps reflect the popular sentiment in Afghanistan

  1. Demonstrations in Jalalabad in favour of the afghan flag
  2. Demonstations in Khost against the Taliban
  3. Flag hoisting at Nangrahar
  4. Protests and firing in Jalalabad
  5. Restoration of the afghan flag in Jalalabad
  6. Women protestors in Kabul
  7. Protests in Kunar province: rehoisting of flag and demonstrations

Some signs that behind all the PR, the Taliban are still the same

and some signs that the war is not yet fully won by the Taliban:

Source Link

"Any reliable indicators of the popular sentiment in Afghanistan?"

Inference based on battles aren't a reliable indicator of popular sentiment. At best, they are an indicator of the sentiment of the army personnel. A better indicator may be from afghan sources/public figures who are apolitical.

The below is from popular afghan public/sports figures who are not politically affiliated: Rashid Khan and Nabi

Rashid Khan's twitter message

"My country is in chaos,thousand of innocent people, including children & women, get martyred everyday, houses & properties being destructed.Thousand families displaced..Don’t leave us in chaos."

Mohammed Nabi's twitter message

"I appeal to the leaders of the world; please don't let Afghanistan go into chaos. We need your Support. We want Peace."

Conclusion:

  1. Even for people in Afghanistan, the Taliban as an unknown. They don't know what to expect, and don't want chaos.
  2. The people of afghanistan don't have a choice in whether to like Taliban on not. They've been handed over to the Taliban by their army and bad planning on governance transition after Western troop withdrawal.
  3. The popular sentiment in Kabul is that they've been let down - by the west, and their government.