3

In the data from Wikipedia Turkey has religious fractionalization index value 0.0049 which makes it the fifth least fractionalized country.

But from this data it can be seen that %20 percent of the society belongs to different branch of Islam.

Given that why religious fractionalization index is so low for Turkey?

  • Given Kurdish situation, I'm actually very skeptical of such a low index value. Not sure how it's computed. – user4012 Nov 18 '16 at 22:30
  • 1
    Here is a paper also mentioning a "religious fractionalization index" (Alesina’s data (table 3) is identical to the wikipedia data). No computation method is mentioned. I consider it to be implausible/inconsistent/nonsense regarding the Turkey data (1985: 0.0159 2000: 0.4814 Alesina (2003?: 0.0049) – klanomath Nov 19 '16 at 11:46
4

After reading the paper linked in my comment more thoroughly I found the computational method:

It's (1 - (normalized) Herfandahl index). (Page 198, 1st paragraph, sentence 3 in the PDF)
A high number indicates a high fractionalization, a low number (near zero) a mono-religious society (e.g. the State of Vatican City with 100% Roman-Catholics has an RFI of 0.0000 (1 - (1²) = 0.0000)).

Depending on whether you subsume or split all Islamic branches you will get different results for the Religious Fractionalization Index.

Assuming the percentages are:

  • 80% Sunni 18% Alevi 1.5% Alawi (sums up to 99.5%)
  • 0,2% Christian
  • 0,04% Jewish

you get two different results:

1 - (0.995²+0.002²+0.0004²) = 0.00995

or

1 - (0.8²+0.18²+0.015²+0.002²+0.0004²) = 0.327

Alesina probably didn't take into account the different Islamic branches in his Religious Fractionalization Index for some countries and got a result of almost zero for the Turkish society. The same non-distinction was applied to Yemen (~62% Sunni/~38% Shia or 100% Muslim) but probably not to Saudi Arabia (~88% Sunni/12% Shia or 100% Muslim - not considering 1.5 Mio Christian and 0.4 Mio Hindu foreign workers) and an RFI of 0.127 or Afghanistan (~80% Sunni/~20% Shia or 100% Muslim) and an RFI of 0.2717.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.