2

In the U.S., what does it precisely mean that federal courts have limited jurisdiction? I ask because I'm unsure that they cannot hears cases in which the president or the Congress are involved.

Thank you.

6

The term "jurisdiction" means "the power to make official legal decisions and judgements". When a court has limited jurisdiction, that court can only hear certain types of cases. For example, a bankruptcy court can normally only hear bankruptcy cases, and thus has limited jurisdiction.

Federal courts have limited jurisdiction in that only certain types of cases can be heard in them:

  • the constitutionality of a law
  • those involving U.S. (federal) law and treaties
  • those about ambassadors and public ministers
  • disputes between states
  • admiralty law (i.e., maritime law)
  • bankruptcy cases

To determine whether a case can be heard or not (assuming an actual case has been initiated by some party), the following must apply:

  • the plaintiff must have "standing", which means that the plaintiff must have been aggrieved or legally harmed in some way by the defendant
  • The court must have the authority to actually do something to resolve the case
  • the plaintiff must be experiencing ongoing harm or the case is otherwise somehow unresolved; i.e., the case can't be resolved and then dragged back through court

There is a very readable article on the US Courts website covering more details about jurisdiction (and was the source for my lists above).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.