As far as I know the UK is a representative democracy. I think this means small co-located populations send representatives to a central Parliament to act on their behalf in the legislature.

So should that MP always take the majoritarian view (if known) on issues voted on in the legislature, possibly with the exception of those bound by collective responsibility in the cabinet? Are there rules surrounding this?

  • While the UK uses districts ("small co-located populations sending a representative") this is not implied by being a representative democracy. That's just one way of doing it. Other countries do it differently. – Abigail Jan 31 at 17:34
  • I would assume that they are free to take any view that they see fit and later the voters can use their votes if they disagree. – Joe W Jan 31 at 17:35
  • 2

No. MPs are elected as representatives, not delegates. That is to say, their job is to represent their constituents' interests: they are not there as proxy voters for their constituents opinions.

It is not unknown for constituents' interests to be in conflict with those constituents' opinions of what should be done: after all, virtually none of them are specialists in the causes and effects in question, nor do they have access to expert advice on those causes and effects.

The UK is almost exclusively a representative democracy, rather than a direct or participatory democracy. Its referendums are rare and dysfunctional.

There are parliamentary customs that make it easier for the government to carry out policies that were in its election manifesto. But the manifesto does not bind MPs.

Each party can provide guidance as to how it expects its MPs to vote on any particular question; there may be varying degrees of penalty if that guidance is ignored, but the worst that can happen is that the party disowns the MP: it cannot prevent the MP voting in Parliament according to how that MP chooses.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.