Any polls out there indicating the public's pulse on the impeachment? Specifically interested in moderates or independents and swing states.

  • 5
    What research have you done? – user2705196 Nov 7 '19 at 16:57

Nate Silver's website FiveThirtyEight has been collating and adjusting all of the polls related to both starting the impeachment query and conviction.

enter image description here

Source: https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/impeachment-polls/?ex_cid=rrpromo

As you can see support for impeachment was unaffected by the years long Russia gate scandal, but the Ukraine scandal caused support for impeachment and removal to spike. It is now starting to wane a little, but there is still a plurality that supports it by 47% to 45%

Support for impeachment is highly dependent on party affiliation with 83% of Democrats in favor, but only 11% of Republicans. Independents are split with 45% supporting it.

  • 9
    Independents are largely undecided with 45% supporting it., that sounds contradictory. If 45% support it, then unless less than 5% opposite it, those undecided are in a minority. – gerrit Nov 7 '19 at 8:48
  • 4
    Undecided in this context is often meant as the difference between support and opposition being small. If you have a group of people where 45% oppose and 47% support impeachment, that leaves 8% who can easily swing the majority of the whole group either way. – blues Nov 7 '19 at 9:52
  • @CommentersAbove You can always use the edit button to fix posts while the OP is sleeping. – SurpriseDog Nov 7 '19 at 13:43
  • 2
    I am hesitant to change words that change the meaning; especially if I don’t know your intention ;) – Jan Nov 7 '19 at 14:46
  • @gerrit you can have 45% supporting and 46% undecided. leaving 9% against. were does your 5% limit come from? – Federico Nov 11 '19 at 9:06

More than one press article attributed the October jump (e.g. as seen in in SurpriseDog's answer from cumulative 538 data) to have been caused by independents, e.g. as Reuters reported on Oct 23:

Support for impeachment was relatively steady among Republicans and Democrats over the past week but it surged among independents, a group that includes people who neither identify as Democrats nor Republicans and do not favor either party when they vote.

Among independents, 45% said in the latest poll they supported impeachment and 32% said they opposed it, the strongest level of support recorded in more than a year.

A little more than 1 in 3 independents had said they were in favor of impeachment in more than a dozen previous Reuters/Ipsos polls since June 2018. [...]

The [latest] Reuters/Ipsos poll was conducted after several administration officials backed up portions of a government whistleblower’s report that alleged Trump pressured Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelenskiy to investigate one of his main political rivals, former Vice President Joe Biden.

Caveat: it was an on-line poll (self-disclosed margin of error 5 percentage points).

Similarly NPR reported on Oct 10:

The uptick in support in the NPR poll comes mostly from a swing among independents. In late September, more independents disapproved of the inquiry than approved, by a 50-44% margin. Now, in a reversal, more independents approve of the inquiry than disapprove, by a 54-41% margin, a net change of 19 points.

However, as @dsollen correctly pointed out in a comment, in the cross-poll 538 data, cross-tabulated by respondent's leaning, the pro-impeachment Democrats appear to have been surging just/almost as much, although a boost from 70% to nearly 85% is not looking like a swing anymore, so it was perhaps less newsworthy.

enter image description here

(Note: I've cut out the uneventful part of this graph so there's more zoom on the events. The cursor [highlighted number] was roughly on the peak support for Democrats and independents.)

As for swing states, there was a recent NYT/Siena voting intention poll (covered in the 2nd part of an answer of mine to another question), which probably captures the effect of the [recent] impeachment proceedings as well. Although NYT did not report impeachment data from that poll (at least in the article I found), apparently the raw data, does contain a question or two on impeachment, because the Hill summarized that as

A New York Times–Siena College battlegrounds poll released Wednesday found that majorities in Michigan, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Arizona and Florida oppose removing the president from office through impeachment. Majorities or pluralities do support an investigation of Trump, however.

And a Siena page has the raw numbers supporting that:

enter image description here

And a Brookings article has even tabulated the impeachment & removal question from the same poll (but not the other one, just on inquiry) by the leaning of the respondent, i.e. you can see what the independents in the battleground states are saying on that:

enter image description here

(They also break down that by race, in a subsequent table, if you're curios.)

And they also summarize a related question:

Taking swing states as a whole, 47% of voters believe that President Trump’s actions related to Ukraine as well as to investigating former Vice President Biden and his son are “typical of what politicians do” rather than much worse than that of typical politicians (43%). The share of swing state voters taking this dark view of politics ranges from a low of 42% in Florida to a high of 51% in Arizona.

You may also be interested in a more in-depth ABC/Langer poll (published on Nov 1) that asked some "optics" questions about impeachment, including the public's view on how the Democrats handled it, how the Republicans responded, or even on Giuliani's role. Alas the [publicly reported] result of this poll are mostly not broken down by the usual political-leaning respondent categories. But the Giuliani question happened to be reported so:

Further, 60% say it was inappropriate for Trump to involve his personal lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, in U.S. policy toward Ukraine, with 83% of Democrats saying so and 61% of independents saying so, compared with 32% of Republicans.

  • 1
    I'm not sure this is true. If you scroll down a little on 538 own polls (here: projects.fivethirtyeight.com/impeachment-polls) you can see they divide support by democratic, independent, and republican voters. You can see that democrats have roughly the same degree of uptick in support for impeachment as independents did post the Ukraine scandal. Since there are far more democrats then independents (at least n the likely to vote category) that would imply to me it's democrats that play the largest role in the uptick of support. – dsollen Nov 7 '19 at 17:27

You must log in to answer this question.