9

I have often heard the statement that the British Conservative party would be considered left-wing if they were to run in the US - in some cases further left than the Democrats.

How true is this statement, and how might other British parties fit on the American political spectrum?

Edit: By spectrum, I am referring specifically to the social/economic “political compass” style spectrum.

  • 7
    If we take things like lavender issues & affirmative action, the Democrats are quite far to the left, even to the standards of various European countries. If we look at other topics, like health care, wars of aggression, and the role of government, a moderate Democrat is likely to take some positions that are considered far right in several European countries. What I'm getting at is that the question is rather broad and risks being closed if it doesn't narrow down which exact political spectrum it's asking about. – Peter Nov 14 '19 at 19:35
  • 1
    Fair enough, I’ll edit the question to refer specifically to the popular economic/social 2-dimensional spectrum. – CDJB Nov 14 '19 at 19:39
12

The notion of right or left is rather fuzzy in practice. There's some truth in the statement that led to your question with respect to a few policy aspects; not so much with respect to others.

For instance, consider the UK's single payer health care system. The Conservatives know it is political suicide for them to seek to privatizing it. The US equivalent would be to have medicare for all in place, Republican grassroots fighting tooth and nail to keep it around, and Republican politicians campaigning to expand its budget.

Gun rights are another example. The UK is among the countries with the least gun circulation.

For the rest, the UK Conservatives are your typical conservative right-wing coalition outfit: pro big business, pro small government (in theory, at least), pro fiscal responsibility (also in theory, at least), pro limited immigration, with traditionalist tendencies, with fringe members exhibiting vague to blatant xenophobic tendencies, etc.

Labour's positions under Corbyn are clearcut populist left. Its policy positions are very close to those advocated by e.g. Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez in the US. Before Momentum activists took over, the coalition's leadership leaned more center-center-left, as in firmly centrist -- which prompted arch-libertarian Margaret Thatcher to quip that her greatest achievement was Tony Blair. A US equivalent to a UK Blairite might look somewhat like Pete Buttigieg.

The Lib Dems are pro-market centrists with vague libertarian tendencies. It's nothing like Ron Paul fundamentalists, mind you; just a run the mill keep businesses happy outfit, without the social conservatism that is often associated with it. (To answer a comment: see for instance how the Tea Party movement, which originally was a purely libertarian group, got overtaken by the Christian right a mere few weeks into its existence.) In a 19th century continental European setting, they'd almost certainly have been filed under liberals -- that is, pro-democracy and pro-bourgeoisie, but not progressives. I'd wager many US independents would identify with it.

The Brexit party is a single issue party. There isn't much to say about it besides that it is first and foremost about Nigel Farage, and that its MEPs (and supporters) include a hodgepodge of libertarian fundamentalists, xenophobes, and former communists. It's a bit hard to say what it stands for exactly. The US equivalent might look like the alt-right without the white supremacist connotations -- or put another way, disgruntled, disillusioned, and disenfranchised voters.

The Green party is, well, green. They don't really fit in the usual right/left spectrum, except perhaps somewhere to the left. There actually is a US Green Party which resembles them on most policy issues (it only has traction in California).

The various nationalist groups are a varied bunch. The Scotts and Welsh are centrists leaning left. The Irish range from center left to hard right insofar as I'm aware.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    "without the social conservatism that is usually associated with it." Social conservatism is usually associated with libertarianism? In what way? At least as a person in the U.S., the main social issues that I would associate with libertarians are things like decriminalizing drug use, easing restrictions on immigration, and things of that nature... which are very much the opposite of what most social conservatives here would support. – reirab Nov 14 '19 at 22:40
  • The LibDems do have heritage from a 19th century Liberal party, although obviously a century's distance does allow some drift. I'm not sure it's accurate, though, to say that they're "not progressives". If you check out the manifestos for the internal party elections which are currently going on (I won't link, because it would probably 404 in a couple of weeks), a good number of the candidates place emphasis on their progressive credentials. (Disclaimer: I'm a party member, although not active in any real sense). – Peter Taylor Nov 15 '19 at 11:06
  • 6
    "The Conservatives know it is political suicide for them to seek to privatizing it." The word "openly" should probably be inserted between "to" and "seek" – Jontia Nov 15 '19 at 11:33
  • @PeterTaylor: In the sentence's intended 19th century context, progressive means socialist for all practical intents (as in pro massive redistribution of wealth to achieve a more egalitarian society). – Denis de Bernardy Nov 15 '19 at 12:08
  • 1
    Hmm... The added example doesn't seem to describe American libertarians at all, though, just how an initially-libertarian movement got hijacked by non-libertarians on the right. I think you'll find most American libertarians (Ron Paul included) were rather annoyed by this. Just like how founding members of the House Freedom Caucus left it after it was similarly eventually hijacked by non-libertarians on the right. That doesn't mean American libertarians are socially conservative, but rather just than they're outnumbered by social conservatives. – reirab Nov 15 '19 at 14:07

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .