MP Grayling was defeated in the Prime Minister's attempt to make him the chair of the Intelligence and Security Committee today. I've seen speculation (unsourced) that the Prime Minister and Number 10 are now seeking for ways to remove the new elected chair, Julian Lewis, with one possibility being a vote in the Commons.

Does the Commons have the authority to vote on a chair of one of its committees? If so, when is the earliest such a vote could be scheduled for? What other ways could No. 10 use to remove Lewis?

  • As far as I can tell the PM backing a candidate for the chair of this committee is unprecedented let alone acting to remove a chair that they did not support.
    – Jontia
    Jul 16, 2020 at 8:51
  • @Jontia: Well, everything to get rid of unelected bureaucrats and to make the government more transparent...
    – gktscrk
    Jul 16, 2020 at 9:31

1 Answer 1


Generally, yes, since the partial implementation of the Wright Committee's recommendations in 2010 under the coalition government, chairs of most select committees are elected by the whole House. A list of these committees can be found in Standing Order 122B.

However, several select committees, including the Intelligence and Security Committee, have a chair elected by their members. In this case, the Justice and Security Act 2013 sets out who is eligible to become a member of the committee in the first place, and the procedure which governs the election of the chair:

(4) A person is not eligible to become a member of the ISC unless the person—

  • (a) is nominated for membership by the Prime Minister, and
  • (b) is not a Minister of the Crown.

(5) Before deciding whether to nominate a person for membership, the Prime Minister must consult the Leader of the Opposition.

(6) A member of the ISC is to be the Chair of the ISC chosen by its members.

That being said, there are ways in which the chair could be removed by No. 10, several of which are explained in Schedule 1 of the Act:

(2) A member of the ISC vacates office if—

  • (a) the person ceases to be a member of the House of Parliament by virtue of which the person is a member of the ISC,
  • (b) the person becomes a Minister of the Crown, or
  • (c) a resolution for the person’s removal is passed in the House of Parliament by virtue of which the person is a member of the ISC.

So Lewis could be removed from the committee by making him a government minister (highly unlikely), or by voting for his removal in the Commons (more likely). This would allow a new chair to be elected. As the government has a healthy Commons majority, this could be accomplished as soon as time could be allocated in the Commons timetable. It goes without saying that this would be unpopular politically, however given that Lewis has also lost the Conservative whip, we could be past that point.

Alternatively, No. 10 could pass primary legislation to reform the election of the committee chair, bypassing the above legislation. Perhaps the best way to do this, politically speaking, would be under the guise of implementing the rest of the Wright Reforms; in 2019, the Liason Committee recommended that election of select committee chairs by the whole House be extended to cover all committees:

The direct election of most select committee chairs by secret ballot of the whole House has led to more confident committees, with an increasing willingness to innovate and push the boundaries. We recommend that the relevant changes to Standing Order No. 122B be made to extend chair elections to all select committees.

Bear in mind, however, that primary legislation would take a while to pass through Parliament, and assuming that the Wright Committee recommendations are adhered to, the election would still be by secret ballot, meaning that the government could not exert pressure on its MPs to elect their preferred candidate.

  • 1
    Very good & thorough answer!
    – gktscrk
    Jul 16, 2020 at 4:42
  • 2
    Is it worth highlighting that 4) in the first quote is about being nominated for membership, not for the Chair? The intro to the quote may conflate the two issue on a first read. As far as I can tell being backed by the PM for the chairmanship is unprecedented.
    – Jontia
    Jul 16, 2020 at 8:56
  • 1
    @Jontia yes, good point - I'll try to clarify that.
    – CDJB
    Jul 16, 2020 at 8:57

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .