2

In the current conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan, Turkey supports the latter. What made them choose one over the other?

2
2

As a Turk, my guess would be historical and ethnic links. I hear the phrase ''We are 2 different states but we are the same nation'' all the time in social media, kind of like China and Taiwan. The only difference is that Azerbaijan and Turkey have very similar ideologies.

What did you even expect? Who can Turkey trust, not only in that area, but in the whole world? Ties with the USA aren't getting any better since the Brunson crisis, Russia is a very strategic superpower that only looks for its interests, Justice and Development Party (AKP) always talks trash about EU to gain support from the conservatives and ultra-right...

Turkey's only eternal friends are Pakistan and Azerbaijan.

3
  • 2
    Since the ROC and PRC (Taiwan and China) are in perpetual state of war, with neither recognising even the other's right to exist... I'm not sure that's the best analogy!
    – James K
    Oct 11 '20 at 22:22
  • You are right but I said ''kinda'' and I said that Turkey and Azerbaijan doesn't have very different ideologies. What I meant was that both China and Taiwan have the same ethnic root, but yeah, they are always competing in some manner and it's not going to stop. Oct 12 '20 at 10:17
  • @JamesK That's about 30 years out of date. It is only China that considers it an ongoing war and refuses to recognize the other's right to exist. Taiwan has defensive measures set up in case China does something, but Taiwan considers the war as history and Taiwan recognizes China's right to exist. Any claims to Chinese territory that Taiwan maintains on paper are due to the fact that both America and China demand that Taiwan maintain those claims, and America only makes those demands because China does.
    – Readin
    Jan 31 at 2:58
10

Turkey and Azerbaijan have historical and cultural links.

They are both Muslim countries engaged in a long term dispute with Orthodox Christian countries.

Between 1914 and 1923 there was a series of expulsions and massacres collectively known as a the Armenian Genocide, in which about 1.5 million Armenians, then under Turkish/Ottoman rule died and many more were displaced. Since then Turkey has been an enemy of Armenia.

2
  • 5
    I'm guessing that they were enemies before the genocide. People rarely decide to murder their friends. Oct 9 '20 at 21:09
  • @ArcanistLupus "Enemy" is probably not the right word. The relationship between perpetrators of a genocide and their victims is usually not that simple.
    – Roland
    Oct 14 '20 at 11:18
5

The Azerbaijani language is not only a Turkic language like Turkish but even shares the same Western Oghuz subgroup. This points to a long common history of the ancestors of modern Azerbaijani and Turkish speakers. There still seems to be a reasonable degree of mutual intelligibility between speakers of Turkish and Azerbaijani. In addition, Azerbaijanis like Turkish are considered a Turkic people, meaning they did not supplant a previously spoken language when acquiring a Turkic one but are most likely part of the original Turkic speakers. Finally, both peoples are overwhelmingly muslim, adding to their shared identity. It is believed that the ancestors did not settle in Anatolia or the Caucasus region until the Middle Ages.

By contrary, Armenian is an Indo-European language, a completely different language family. Armenians have settled the Caucasus region since at least antiquity, with some sources saying up to 4000 years – this already means that they are a different people than the Turkic peoples of the previous paragraph. The possibly final nail in the coffin is the fact that Armenians have long been christians – they are credited as the first state to adopt Christianity and the Old City of Jerusalem has a traditional Armenian Christian quarter beside the Jewish, Muslim and Christian quarters.

Finally, one cannot touch on the question of Turkish-Armenian relations without mentioning the Armenian Genocide. There is far more to be said about this topic than would fit into a single answer but extremely briefly tensions had been building up between the Turkish majority and the Armenian minority in the Ottoman empire which led to a series of smaller preceding massacres starting in the 1890’s and finally to a significant purge which left around 1.5 million Armenians dead by 1923. Turkey and Azerbaijan both deny that this genocide happened (or maybe they merely object to calling it a genocide) which, as you may imagine, is a bit of a difficult issue between Turkey and Armenia.

Tl;dr: there is next to nothing outside a longer shared border to suggest Turkish support of Armenia but there are tons of reasons for Turkey to support and be allied with Azerbaijan.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .