21

Anecdotally, I have found that anyone I personally know who is a first-generation immigrant from either Africa, or non-Hispanic Caribbean (less so) is a lot more likely to be "righter-wing" in their views, especially socially, than African Americans (defined here to be descendants of Africans who were brought to Americas as slaves). The dynamics seems to track similar to some other ethnic groups (Jews or Slavs who are American born vs first generation immigrants), but all I have are personal impressions.

Is there any polling data - either in terms of party-support election polls, or polls on social issues (specific issues I'd be interested in would be one or more of: gun control, corporal punishment, school discipline, single motherhood, individual responsibility, LGBT issues, etc... - the list is basically culled from items where I observed people having more in common with my views than with predominante-polling views of most African-Americans) to show if there's a convergence/divergence in the two demographics?

I'd prefer single-issue surveys/polls to generic "who you voted for" polls if they exist, and prefer more-sound polls (as 538 would define it) to random internet surveys.

  • 3
    I'd be shocked if there wasn't a massive gulf in opinion when it comes to same-sex marriage. Polls consistently find that upwards of 95% of countries like Nigeria think homosexuality is morally wrong. I don't see 59% of African immigrants supporting same-sex marriage like African-Americans do. washingtonpost.com/politics/… – TenthJustice Oct 28 '14 at 14:01
  • 1
    I know of no polls (I'm sure they exist) but this seems fairly common. New immigrants from culturally conservative cultures likely are more culturally conservative than Americans (in general). – user1530 Oct 28 '14 at 18:11
  • 4
    It would certainly depend on the intent of immigration. Some immigrants are trying to escape their culture. Some are trying to find work/avoid war and bring their culture with them. – user1530 Oct 28 '14 at 18:18
  • 4
    (And I have a hunch that--at least specific to Africa--part of this cultural difference may be the extent and type of Catholicism being brought over. The Catholic church in America vs. Africa are quite different at the moment in terms of cultural norms and expectations) – user1530 Oct 28 '14 at 18:22
  • 4
    @DA But are most immigrants from Africa catholics? – Relaxed Nov 2 '14 at 19:04
3

I will update with references when I have a chance, but I am currently writing from memory. The short answer is that there isn't much good polling of these populations on the issues of concern to you, in part, because both of these populations are fairly small, and both of these populations are highly fragmented internally into sub-populations whose views are not necessarily cohesive.

Musings on the immigrant African's place in American politics without statistics can be found in a 2007 Op-Ed piece in the Los Angeles Times.

The Caribbean

There are an estimated 2.88 million Afro-Caribbean people in the United States out of 37.7 million African-Americans overall as of 2010. But, this population is divided amongst many national immigration stories. Some survey data on Afro-Caribbean attitudes on some issues can be found here and in the study it reviews.

Cuban immigrants, some of whom are considered black, tend to vote Republican and are more conservative. This is in part because Cuban immigrants in the U.S. tend to be people who fled a left wing regime in Cuba as political refugees, many from around the time that Castro's regime was put in place. There is quite a bit of polling data to support this conclusion. About 85% of Cuban immigrants and about 64% of Cubans in Cuba consider themselves to be white. There are about 180,000 black Cubans in the United States.

Puerto Rican immigrants, some of whom are black, tend to vote Democratic and to be left of central politically. This is particularly clear in greater New York City where Puerto Rican migration to the U.S. is concentrated. There are about 4.6 million Puerto Ricans in the mainland U.S. of whom about half identify as black (8.7%) or of mixed race.

Dominican Republic immigrants, most of whom are black, tend to vote Democratic and to be left of center politically. I am not aware of specific issues upon which they differ from African-Americans. Many Dominican immigrants are also concentrated in Great New York City, although there may also be other areas of regional concentration. There are about 1.4 million Dominicans in the United States, of whom 30% identify as white, 13% identify as black, and the remainder identify as some other race or mixed race. Many Dominican immigrants in the U.S. are dual citizens who are participate politically in the Dominican Republic.

There are about 830,000 Haitian Americans in the United States, many of whom live in Florida. Many are black. They tend to favor Democrats.

Other racially African people from other parts of the Caribbean tend to migrate in current or colonial powers associated with those countries in Europe (e.g. the U.K., France, and the Netherlands). So, there has been relatively little immigration from these countries in the Caribbean to the U.S., and I am not aware of polling analyzing their political tendencies or views as a distinct sub-group. Studies on the voting patterns of these populations in Europe would probably provide insight into U.S. voting patterns.

Africa

There hasn't been a lot of migration from Africa to the U.S., mostly because other countries (e.g. France in West Africa, Central Africa, and Northwest Africa; the U.K. in Southern Africa, Nigeria, Egypt, Sudan and East Africa; Italy in Libya and Ethiopia; Portugal in Mozambique) have historical colonial relationships with those countries and provided more natural targets for migrants. The only country in Africa with a historical colonial-type relationship to the U.S. is Liberia, and to the best of my knowledge that relationship has not given rise to significant enough migration to the U.S. to create a notable political community in the U.S.

In all Africans make up 3.3% of U.S. immigrants in recent times from more than a dozen major source countries and a variety of religious backgrounds. A very high percentage have college educations.

In 2009, 74.4 percent of the African-born population reported their race as Black, either alone or in combination with another race. African immigrants identified as Black at a much higher rate than the native born (14.0 percent) and the foreign born overall (8.6 percent), and accounted for 33.3 percent of all foreign-born Blacks and 2.7 percent the total Black population in the United States.

Racial self-identification varied widely by African country of origin. For example, nearly all immigrants from Ghana (99.7 percent), Somalia (99.3 percent), Cameroon (98.8 percent), Nigeria (98.7 percent), and Ethiopia (98.2 percent) reported their race as Black, either alone or in combination with another race, compared to 4.6 percent of Algerians, 5.6 percent of Egyptians, 8.1 percent of Moroccans, 13.8 percent of South Africans, 56.7 percent of Tanzanians, and 65.7 percent of Cape Verdeans.

From here. More background on African immigrant populations in the U.S. can be found here. References to studies of economic and educational prospects of African immigrants can be found here.

Muslim immigrants (a significant sub-set of whom are Sub-Saharan African) tend to vote Democratic but not as reliably as African-Americans (who are 83% Democrats or Democratic party leaning v. 8% Republicans or Republican leaning), and Muslim immigrants have more conservative political views than African-Americans, on average. Some of the data is in the General Social Survey, and some of this is in relatively recent political polling. Polling more often distinguishes immigrant Muslims from native born Muslims, than it does sub-Saharan African immigrant Muslims from other immigrant Muslims.

The Atlantic Magazine has a lengthy discussion of the Muslim vote in 2016. Only 15% of American Muslims backed Trump. 27% of American Muslims backed Bernie Sanders in the primary. More complete polling data on American Muslims in 2016-2017 is available here. About 57% of African Muslims voted in 2016 (v. 64% of Arab Muslims and 75% of Asian Muslims). Muslims tend to support the Black Lives Matter movement. About 25% of American Muslims are black and a significant share of that percentage involves native born individuals rather than immigrants.

Another survey of the electoral and attitude positions of American Muslims on the eve of the 2016 election can be found here. Some of the key findings were:

 72% of Muslim voters said they will vote to elect Hillary Clinton, while 4% said they will vote for Donald Trump, 3% will vote for Jill Stein, and 2% will vote for Gary Johnson.

 44% of Muslim voters consider themselves moderate, while 25% consider themselves liberal, and 11% consider themselves conservative.

 The percentage of those who said they are closer to the Democratic Party remained constant, from 66% in a similar poll taken in 2012, to 67% today, after having increased from 49% in a similar poll taken in 2008.

 Affiliation with the Republican Party remained relatively steady, 6% today, 9% in 2012 and 8% in 2008.

In 2006, 17% of Muslims were Republicans.

Only about 5% of Muslim voters, as opposed to Muslims generally, however, in the U.S., have African ancestry. Still, a Voice of America story in 2016 on the shift of Muslims to the Democratic party, would likely have applicability to many immigrant populations:

Once seen as a "natural" Republican constituency, Muslim-Americans are increasingly leaning Democratic, and they are expected to vote in record numbers for Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton in the U.S. presidential election in November.

From overwhelmingly voting for George W. Bush in the 2000 election to backing Clinton in the current cycle, the Muslim shift in political allegiance has been precipitous, leading some critics to lament a lost Republican opportunity to keep an increasingly influential voting bloc.

According to surveys conducted after the election, more than 70 percent of Muslims voted for Bush, and most of the 50,000 Muslim votes in Florida went to the Republican candidate. . . .

If there was a high-water mark in the love affair between Muslim-Americans and the Republican Party, it was the 2000 election. In 2004, more than 90 percent of Muslim-Americans voted for John Kerry; in 2008 and 2014, Muslims voted for Barack Obama, by 89 percent and 85 percent, respectively, according to several estimates. . . .

In the 2011 Pew survey, 70 percent of Muslims in America described themselves as Democrats or leaning Democratic, while 11 percent said they were Republicans or leaning Republican. Those numbers have held relatively steady since then. McCaw of CAIR cited another poll that showed 55 percent of Muslim-Americans describe themselves as moderate, while 26 percent identify as liberal. . . .

Many analysts thought conservative Muslims and Republicans shared common views on issues such as homosexuality and the role of government. The 2011 Pew survey showed that Muslim-Americans have grown "considerably more accepting of homosexuality" since 2007. On the role of government, the survey found that 68 percent of Muslim-Americans preferred a bigger government providing more services over a smaller government providing fewer services.

"So not only do they switch parties and now are voting Democratic, but they're also adopting some of the policies and positions and ethics" of the Democratic Party, McCaw said. "Traditionally, a number of immigrants from the Middle East or South Asia are more socially conservative, and there was a place for them in the Republican Party. But I think as people grow and develop in America, [they] definitely change their views and preferences over time; and more importantly, their children grow up here and they might be voting different than their parents previously had."

I haven't seen any hard data on the voting patterns of African immigrants who are not Muslim, mostly because the number of African immigrants who can vote is small, even in places like Minneapolis and Denver that have significant numbers of Christian African immigrants (e.g. Ethiopian Orthodox Christians), since relatively few are naturalized citizens.

Anecdotally, in my own dealings with the African immigrant community, they tend to be Democratic party leaning (since the Republican party hasn't been very welcoming to them), but are more conservative on some political issues than African Americans (e.g. issues related to gender and domestic violence and economics). But, my personal dealings with this community as a lawyer and local party officer are not scientific samples.

The Egyptian Christian immigrants that I have encountered (who are racially "North African" rather than sub-Saharan African) have been "swing voters" who are more conservative on many issues, especially social issues, than Democrats, but also suspicious of xenophobic attitudes in the Republican party and not as conservative as Southern whites, for example. Again, the numbers are too small to constitute even an informal statistical sample.

Studies on the voting patterns of these populations in Europe would probably provide insight into U.S. voting patterns. For example, immigrant Africans tend to be much more active participants in religion than native born people in the countries where they live.

A Voice of America piece notes concerns from an African immigrant political lobby about relationships between the U.S. and countries in Africa and about immigration law.

A piece of African immigrant Republicans from 2008 from PBS is here. It notes that Minnesota, with 60,000 to 90,000 African born residents is the fastest growing African immigrant population of any U.S. state and that this population leans heavily Democratic although it sent one delegate to the GOP convention in 2008.

0

WARNING: Take whatever I say with a grain of salt. You may have to perform more research than I did to satisfy the conditions listed, due to the nature of this query, and whether or not anyone has thought of collecting this specific data yet.

From what I have read in your request, you appear to be asking about the Political Spectrum/Map, and not Party Affiliation. Therefore, I will attempt to limit the results to data that can apply to either Political Spectrum and Political Party Affiliation, or Political Spectrum only. In many polls and studies that are available online, the data collected for this type of relation is categorized by "major" Ethnic groups. In this case, "major" ethnic groups include the following:

  • Black
  • White
  • Asian
  • Jewish
  • Hispanic

You need additional data, to increase the specificity of these results and find a valid trend. Data that can assist in grouping the previous results more clearly includes:

  • Gender
  • Religious 'Stance'
    • Religiously unaffiliated
    • Religiously affiliated
      • If so, what specific affiliations?
  • Generation/Age
    • Silent generation
    • Millennial generation
    • etc.
  • College education and above
  • Below College education
  • Geography/Birth location

The most-descriptive ones will most likely be Religious 'Stance' and Geography. Polls including these results, when used in addition to the 'major' Ethnic groups, can give more descriptive power to the results. In sorting the data by 'major' Ethnic groups and Religious 'Stance', a statistician can take advantage of trends in Religious 'Stance' that are linked to its prominence in certain Geographic areas, in addition to the nominal Geographic implications presented in the 'major' Ethnic groups. However, this pretty much shows that simply collecting more Geographical data initially will clean up the results better than what I have just suggested.

As such, I believe the following will be a good starting point for what you are seeking:

This map provides data related to the Political Spectrum and people's Geographical location. As such, this data should be more in-line with what you requested. However, I would be careful with the data taken from this source - it wasn't made by an official authority, and presents no citations to support its data. From the lens/stance of 'Accuracy over Time-frame', and the fact that statistical predictions can be used to extrapolate what should now be the current state of these trends, I personally prefer other available maps.

Finding the specific data is going to be a bit difficult. I would check the Census and public FBI records, to see in there's anything available. These sources tend to be a bit more descriptive in how the data is organized.

*For the complete answer, please go here. I can't post the complete answer here, due to certain limitations.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.