17

Yesterday, new Vice President Kamala Harris presided over the swearing-in of 3 new Senators, including her own replacement. This required her to read a statement which had her own name in it, so she was referring to herself in the 3rd person. She even remarked at the time how weird that felt.

My question is: How weird was that? Harris may represent a lot of firsts in taking the office, first female, first black, first south-Asian VP, but she's hardly the first to have to vacate a Senate seat in order to assume the office. Is it normal for a new VP to preside over the swearing-in of their own replacement in the Senate (or the House for that matter)?

Does it have something to do with the party balance in the Senate? (I know that the 50/50 split is rather unusual.) i.e.: If there were one less or one more Democrat in the Senate, would McConnell or Schumer have taken that role? (In fact since this was the swearing-in ceremony for the new Senators, and Warnock and Ossoff were not technically in office until a few minutes after that, wouldn't the Republicans still be the majority party at that moment?

0
18

This is mostly to do with the date of Harris' resignation as Senator. She submitted her letter of resignation to California Governor Gavin Newsom on Jan 18th, two days before being sworn in as VP. Recent Vice Presidents who resigned from their Senate seats did so earlier - with the consequence that their appointed replacement assumed their seat before inauguration day.

The most recent VP who swore in their replacement was Charles Curtis, who resigned as Kansas Senator on March 4th, 1929. His replacement, Henry J. Allen, was appointed by the Governor on April 1st, and took the oath of office on April 15th, administered by now Vice President Curtis.

enter image description here

ADMINISTRATION OF OATH TO SENATORS
The VICE PRESIDENT. The Chief Clerk will call the names of Senators elect who did not take the oath of office at the special session of the Senate in March, and they, with the Senator designate from Kansas, will present themselves at the desk and receive the oath of office.
The Chief Clerk called the names of Mr. CUTTING, Mr. LA FOLLETTE, and Mr. SHIPSTEAD.
Mr. SCHALL. I desire that the announcement that my colleague the Senator from Minnesota [Mr. SHIPSTEAD] is detained by reason of serious illness may stand for the day.
Mr. CUTTING escorted by Mr. WATERMAN, Mr. LA FOLLETTE escorted by Mr. NORRIS, and Mr. ALLEN escorted by Mr. CAPPER advanced to the Vice President's desk; and the oath prescribed by law having been administered to them, they took their seats in the Senate.

71 Cong. Rec. (Bound) - Volume 71, Part 1

Below are all the other subsequent Senators who resigned their seats to become Vice President - in each case, their replacement was sworn in before they became VP. Then VP-elect Biden did attend the swearing-in ceremony of Kaufman, but obviously was not eligible to preside.

Outgoing Senator / VP Successor in Senate Sworn in on
Joe Biden Edward Kaufman Jan 16th, 2009
Al Gore Harlan Mathews Jan 3rd, 1993
Dan Quayle Dan Coats Jan 3rd, 1989
Walter Mondale Wendell R. Anderson Dec 30th 1976
Hubert Humphrey Walter Mondale Dec 30th 1964
Lyndon B. Johnson William A. Blakley Jan 3rd 1961
Richard Nixon Thomas Kuchel Jan 2nd 1953
Alben W. Barkley Garrett Withers Jan 20th 1949
but before the inauguration of Barkley
(see Congressional Record)
Harry Truman Frank Briggs Jan 18th 1945
20th Amendment changes inauguration
date from March 4th to Jan 20th
Charles Curtis Henry Justin Allen April 15th 1929

In conclusion, this is fairly unusual, but only because Senators who are successfully elected to the office of Vice President tend to step down as Senator early enough for their replacement to be sworn in by someone else.

3
  • Follow up then, if not the new VP, who was responsible for swearing in these other replacement Senators? Is it the Majority Leader? Leader of the new Senator's party? The outgoing VP? Or does it not matter, could just be whoever they choose in each case? Jan 21 at 17:07
  • 3
    @DarrelHoffman it's the President of the Senate, be that the Vice President, or the President pro tempore. This can technically be any Senator, but in practice is usually the most senior Senator from the majority party. In this case, had Harris not presided, Republican Chuck Grassley would have done so in his role as President pro tempore. After the Senators were sworn in, the Democrats were in control of the Senate, and Grassley was replaced by Democrat Patrick Leahy.
    – CDJB
    Jan 21 at 17:52
  • @CDJB And while the VP doesn't often preside over the Senate, they typically show up to swear in new members.
    – cpast
    Jan 22 at 4:12

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .