8

Apparently, the late Tony Benn, once a Labour MP for Bristol South East and Chesterfield, once said:

The way the government treats refugees is very instructive because it shows you how they would treat the rest of us if they thought they could get away with it.

When and in what context did Tony Benn say this?

2
  • 1
    I found that Benn quote very widely introduced with "once said" but no checkable source. – Michael Harvey Mar 18 at 9:12
  • @Michael Harvey: In the case of e e cummings, it was deliberate. Agreed. Well, this is why I'm asking. But given that Benn is eminently quotable it's perhaps not surprising he gets quoted without 'checkable sources'. This, in my experience, tends to happen to quotable people ... – Mozibur Ullah Mar 18 at 9:16
11

He didn't. Although this quote is often misattributed to Benn, including recently in the House of Commons itself by Bell Ribero-Addy MP (Hansard), the quote actually comes from the Scottish journalist and writer Neal Ascherson.

Writing for the Independent in January 1996, Ascherson describes his take on the al-Masari affair in an article entitled If we teach children morality, what will we say about the arms trade?.

The al-Masari affair overflows in all directions with moral relativism. My own view is that to expel a political asylum-seeker because his country threatens to cancel business contracts with Britain is absolutely wrong. And it is not only wrong but dangerous in the long term to us all. This is because of one of the Laws of Politics that I wrote long ago into my little black notebook: "The way a state treats its aliens is the way it would treat its own subjects if it dared".

Ascherson was subsequently paraphrased in the Guardian by Francis Wheen, who wrote in 1999:

We should always watch how politicians treat refugees, Neal Ascherson once wrote, because that's how they would treat the rest of us if they thought they could get away with it.

This seems to be where the more recent framing of the quote has come from.

As for what the al-Masari affair refers to; Mohammad al-Masari is a Saudi political dissident who fled Saudi Arabia in 1993, and sought asylum in the UK. He successfully fought against the British government's attempts to deport him in 1996. This is the context in which Ascherson presented the quote, although as the above excerpt shows, he had come up with it long beforehand.

Note: For some reason, the Independent's website shows a 2011 timestamp on the digitised article. The article is visible, however, in their Jan 21st 1996 archive.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .