4

The 20th Knesset seems to be heading for a 61-member coalition (see here).

If a single member from one of the parties in the coalition decides to transfer to a party in the opposition, would that cause the coalition to become invalidated, as there would no longer be a majority? Or, because it started with a majority and no whole party left, perhaps the government would still be functional.

3
  • Your question doesn't match your body. Are you asking if one MK could bring down a 61 MK, or whether 60 MK's could bring down a 60 MK coalition. – Publius May 6 '15 at 12:53
  • Whether a single MK switching, which leaves 60, brings down the coalition. It amounts to the same thing. – Scimonster May 6 '15 at 13:40
  • It doesn't, because he'd still need the 59 MK opposition on his side as well, but I understand your question now. – Publius May 7 '15 at 15:09
3

It would not immediately invalidate the coalition, but it could prevent the government from doing any business without negotiation with the opposition. Measures with cross party support could still pass. It could also result in the opposition passing a motion of no confidence, which would invalidate the coalition.

As noted in the comments, this is not really 1 MK bringing down the but 61 MKs bringing down the government.

In fact the 20 Knesset survived, and the Coalition was strengthened by another minor party, Yisrael Beiteinu, joining.

An analogous situation which did result in the collapse of a government arose in the UK in 1979. One labour MP was mortally ill. Despite his determination to vote, his party leader told him not to risk his health by travelling to parliament. As a result, the Labour party lot a vote of confidence by one vote, causing the governing coalition to collapse and a general election to be held. (The MP, Alfred Broughton, died a few days later)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .