1

Many BSF and Pakistani Rangers personnel have been claimed to have been killed. This has been continuing for many years. Neither government has taken the responsibility for this violation which doesn't seems possible.

Several attempts of peace talks have been unsuccessful. Many civilians have also been killed and injured as a result of the almost daily ceasefire violations. Why is this happening, why has no-one intervened, and what steps could be taken to resolve this conflict?

1

Why this happens

India and Pakistan fought 3 major wars, 1947-48 , 1965 ,1971 and some more wars like that of Kargil in 1999 and of Siachin.

After the defeat of 1971, Pakistan knew very well that it was not possible for it to win a war against India.

So it decided to use the terrorist/Mujahideens created by US in Afghanistan against India. Later it created it's own.

When border infiltration increased, India decided to build the fencing and increased patrolling. The result was decreased infiltration. So to help terrorist infiltrate in India, Pakistan violates ceasefire and attacks Indian posts.

India retaliates, which leads to and endless cycle of deaths on both side. If India won't retaliate, it will be one sided(deaths only on Indian side).

This is not all, but this is the main reason. Others like revenge attacks by BAT and Para SF are other minor reasons


Why no one intervenes

Why would someone want to get unwanted trouble by getting into a fight between two nations with nuclear weapons? US, China etc advise both to keep good situation on border but that's all.


Steps to resolve this

Currently, the only way out seems to be an complete annihilation of either India or Pakistan. But this is very unlikely.

0

the main reason of ceasefire violation on India-Pakistan borders is the provide the safeguard to the militants who want to enter in India. It some time do it for more political reasons, like when there are talks between the higher command from both side, to stop or to affect the peace talk. infiltration is no doubt the main reason but we should also consider the political scenario behind it. We all know that there is complete decentralization of power in Pakistan so they misuse the military to stop the talks between the governments from both side by doing the sporadic incidents near border areas.

0

The main reason for ceasefire violations is mistrust between the two countries, India's will have its reasons and justification for public to show how Pakistan violated the cease-fire ( for e.g. Mujaheddin crossings) and Pakistan will have its evidences like civilian deaths ( especially on border areas that are not Mujaheddin crossing routes). The fact is this is just symptoms not the cause of these violations, the root cause still remains the main issue of Jumma and Kashmir and I personally think that Jumma and Kashmir's root cause is the rivers flowing from it.

We must keep in view the fact that Pakistan is not ( and will not be for a forseeable future) an existential threat to India while vice versa is true. Hence the onus is on far bigger adversary i.e India to manage and downplay as much as possible.

0

Why this happens

India and Pakistan fought 4 major wars,

After the narrow escape of 1999, India understood very well that it was not possible for them to win a war against Pakistan as they are like historic Afghan ruler of Ghazni, Mahmoud, who robbed India in 17 occasions. So they decided to shift their gear to their soft power (economy and Indian diaspora) which is overwhelmingly backed by the West (predominantly the USA), as India gave them a huge market for arms. Later India

  1. Created their own establishments in Afghanistan, Kyrgyzstan, and Iran to wage a proxy war against Pakistan.
  2. Sent their spy Kulbhushan Yadav to finance separatist movements in Baluchistan.
  3. Financing TTP to conduct suicide attacks throughout Pakistan.

When these efforts didn't produce any favorable outcome, India decided to resort to erratic shelling along the border. The result was heavy civilian casualties.

So to help terrorists to continue their chaos in Pakistan, India violates ceasefire and attacks Pakistani posts. When Pakistan retaliates it leads to an endless cycle of deaths on both sides. If Pakistan doesn't retaliate, it will be a one-sided propaganda war.


Why no one intervenes

The West is heavily biased towards India. This bias comes from 3 basic sources,

Source

  1. India's religion and culture
  2. Indian's economy
  3. India's influence or lobby in the West

Steps to resolve this

Currently, the only way out seems to be strengthening Pakistani economy and military power so that Pakistan doesn't have to give a damn to the West to come to the aid of Pakistan.

  • 3
    I wonder if maybe this answer might have just an ever-so-little flint of subjectivety... – Evargalo Sep 28 '17 at 15:55
  • @OlivierPucher, it's not clear to me, what you wanted to say. – user4514 Sep 28 '17 at 16:29
  • 1
    Olivier is using the rhetorical tactic of understatement to point out how obvious it is that the writer of this answer is not being objective in their assessment and has an obvious bias toward one of the countries involved. – Bryan Krause Sep 28 '17 at 19:34
  • 1
    We all have biases, but it is generally preferred here to be as objective where possible, and source what we can of the rest so that criticism of answers (which is helpful) is distinct from criticism of the answerer (which is perhaps less helpful). – user9389 Sep 28 '17 at 20:54
  • 1
    To be clear I did not criticize your bias in this answer, I criticized your defense of your bias. I would like the answer to have a more neutral tone, but you do seem to have enough support to make me tolerant. What I take exception to is the idea that it is normal or right to display a clear bias in answers here. – user9389 Sep 28 '17 at 21:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.