user
  • Member for 6 years, 5 months
  • Last seen more than a month ago
Is the European Union perceived as privileging certain countries?
6 votes

Mr. Riches is blaming the wrong people. The reason that EU immigration is seen as making non-EU immigration more difficult is because xenophobes and other assorted bigots demand that overall ...

View answer
When Sir Jeffrey Donaldson campaigned to leave the EU, how exactly did he think the matter of the border would be resolved?
7 votes

Donaldson may have taken leave campaigners at their word when they said that the UK would either remain a member of the single market, or have unfettered access to it. If that were the case there ...

View answer
Why does Boris Johnson seek to renegotiate the Brexit deal with the EU?
20 votes

The answer to this question dates back to 2019. Theresa May's government rejected the current solution, a border in the Irish Sea, and instead proposed a "backstop" that would keep the ...

View answer
Arguments for Scotland in non-EU United Kingdom?
5 votes

One argument that has been made is that Scotland would lose some access to the UK market, which is a major one for its economy. There seems to be some truth in that, as we have seen that Northern ...

View answer
What is the dispute resolution authority between London and Brussels now?
7 votes

It's a mixture of different systems depending on the context. Exit Deal The UK and EU must each nominate 10 legal experts to form the ‘pool’ of potential panellists. They must jointly nominate five ...

View answer
Explain for kids — Why isn't Northern Ireland demanding a stay/leave referendum like Scotland?
16 votes

Simply because the path to a referendum is very different in Northern Ireland. The Northern Ireland Act 1998, a statute of the Parliament of the United Kingdom, provides that Northern Ireland will ...

View answer
Have issues surrounding the Northern Ireland border been resolved?
19 votes

The Irish Border issue has been temporarily resolved to the point at which the negotiations can proceed. When she was negotiating May described creating a border down the Irish Sea as something that ...

View answer
In Brexit, what does "not compromise sovereignty" mean?
13 votes

It's a largely meaningless slogan that seeks to justify a "hard" brexit, one that cuts as many ties with the EU as possible. Leaving the EU is a huge loss of sovereignty. The UK's ability to ...

View answer
In the absence of a trade deal, and an amended withdrawal agreement, how will smuggling be prevented across the Irish border?
5 votes

Initially the EU will probably try legal means to force the UK to enforce a new border down the Irish Sea. If that fails the point may become moot because Northern Ireland votes to rejoin Ireland in a ...

View answer
What are the benefits of joining CPTPP over conducting FTAs with the individual members?
Accepted answer
2 votes

CPTTP may offer one benefit. A desperate and weakened UK reeling from brexit will be unlikely to get a good deal by negotiating individual agreements. Each country will be looking to exploit the UK's ...

View answer
Is Biden more apt to press for harder terms and/or the renegotiation of the post-Brexit UK–US trade deal if he wins the Presidency?
1 votes

The Democrats have previously said that they would not do a trade deal if the Irish border was not resolved. Given that there seems to be little prospect of resolving it at the moment with the UK ...

View answer
What is preventing the UK and the EU from progressing in the talks on post-Brexit trade?
13 votes

The main blocker is that the UK is not respecting the agreement it made with the EU in the Withdrawal Agreement. It's actually clear from the quotes you provided - the EU has clear and well ...

View answer
Why can't Northern Ireland just have a stay/leave referendum?
9 votes

Northern Ireland could aim for independence, or more likely to become part of Ireland. The latter is known as a "border poll" and has been proposed before. There is in fact a mechanism to trigger a ...

View answer
What constitutes a bad deal for Brexit?
7 votes

Labour defined a successful Brexit as one that retains free trade and access to the single market. Since this has already been ruled out by the UK government, all the available options could now be ...

View answer
Why is a "hard border" between Ireland and Northern Ireland such a problem for EU/UK negotiations around brexit?
8 votes

Beyond the threat of violence, there is also a severe risk of the UK breaking up. The laws governing Northern Ireland require that if there appears to be enough support for reunification with Ireland ...

View answer
Post-Brexit UK-EU trading relationship: Why (not) Canada?
4 votes

The sea separating the EU and the UK is not very wide and there are fast internet links (in fact I get a faster ping to the Netherlands than to London from inside the UK!) The UK also has the same ...

View answer
Why does Brexit threaten the Good Friday Agreement from 1998?
5 votes

A key aspect of the GFA was the removal of all border apparatus on the Island of Ireland. The border was often a target of violence and a physical divider between the two communities. If the UK ...

View answer
Haven't the DUP violated their confidence-and-supply arrangement?
-2 votes

The confidence and supply agreement was basically worthless to begin with. Just a fig leaf to cover up the fact that the Tories bribed the DUP with at least £1.5 billion, arguably a lot more. Since ...

View answer
Why is Labour sticking with Jeremy Corbyn?
4 votes

Corbyn did remarkably well at the last election, making up huge ground against the Tories. Therefore going in to another election he seems like a good bet, as he has a proven track record when it ...

View answer
What does it mean to support the brexit deal but need more time to scrutinise it?
6 votes

Today was only the second reading, which is an agreement on the principal but not the detail. So MPs are saying they agree with leaving the EU with a deal, but not that they accept the deal Boris ...

View answer
Why did the EU agree with a Stormont vote when the Assembly might not even meet?
1 votes

The previous rejection was because the requirement for a supermajority would have give the DUP an effective veto. If the DUP vetoed the arrangement it would open up the Irish border problem again, ...

View answer
How can the British government both obey the Benn Act and still leave without a Brexit deal?
0 votes

The UK government cannot do both those things. Boris Johnson and others in his government who say it can are lying. Guran's suggestion that the government could try to dissuade the EU from granting ...

View answer
Can Boris Johnson invoke the Civil Contingencies Act to suspend the Benn law?
0 votes

Even if he tried to, the courts would likely not be very amused by it and take steps to make sure the Benn Act was enforced anyway. Courts take a dim view of people trying to get around the law on ...

View answer
What does the British parliament hope to achieve by requesting a third Brexit extension?
5 votes

In the short term the stated goal is to prevent no-deal, which many in Parliament see as damaging to the UK. Beyond that being forced to ask for an extension will damage the Tories and their leader ...

View answer
Is a no-deal Brexit illegal, and therefore invalid?
2 votes

Not just the Good Friday Agreement, but now also the Benn Act makes leaving without a deal on 31st October, without the refusal of the EU to grant an extension, illegal. The question of if that would ...

View answer
Customs checks and Brexit
Accepted answer
6 votes

In a word, yes. The backstop, which this idea is supposed to replace, was only ever intended to be used if the UK and EU could not agree on terms by the end of the transition period (currently ...

View answer
Could Boris Johnson face criminal charges for illegally proroguing Parliament?
1 votes

At this point the court has not ruled that what he did was illegal, only that it did not comply with the laws of the land and thus should be voided. If he tries to prorogue again or refuses to follow ...

View answer
Why did Boris Johnson fly home after the prorogation of parliament was declared illegal?
5 votes

It would have looked very bad for Boris if he had not returned, having just lost a major court case and with Parliament meeting to scrutinize his actions. If he had stayed away it would have looked ...

View answer
What happens if the Prime Minister breaks the Benn Act law?
3 votes

If the PM does not obey the law he could be taken to court over the matter. In that case the court could send the letter on his behalf, requesting the extension. However, I think Boris will likely ...

View answer
If the EU does not offer an extension to UK's Article 50 invocation, is the Benn Bill irrelevant?
5 votes

If the extension is rejected there are two options available to Parliament. Pass a law forcing the PM to revoke Article 50. Pass a motion of no confidence in the government, form an alternative ...

View answer
1
2 3 4 5
7