13

There are numerous articles talking about how people are tired of staying in lockdown:

As Greece enters its third week since restrictive measures were first imposed to combat the spread of coronavirus, there is mounting concern that fatigue is setting in amid signs of people beginning to flout the policies.

Speaking to ANT1 TV, the government spokesman Stelios Petsas said the centre-right administration was now considering placing a time limit on the movement of citizens outdoors, the Guardian reports.

Are there any polls which attempt to track how much people are content with staying under lockdown?

  • 7
    Where are you asking about? You'll probably get very different results in different countries – divibisan Apr 10 at 14:34
  • 2
    @divibisan EU or US states would be interesting – JonathanReez Apr 10 at 14:52
  • 4
    @SurpriseDog: polls of how worried Americans are about getting infected by it are meaningless and subjective, given how comparatively few people in the US are still being tested, and people react to media coverage of rising positive counts, and some US test results are backlogged for weeks, which largely defeats the purpose. – smci Apr 11 at 9:09
  • 2
    I think most people around the world realize it's better to experience fatigue from quarantine than being dead or being responsible for killing others. – RockPaperLz- Mask it or Casket Apr 11 at 11:44
  • 3
    How people "feel" is very relevant to how politicians make public policy decisions. They respond to public sentiment first, actual data second. You may think its illogical and wrongheaded, but ultimately that's the way democracy works. – SurpriseDog Apr 11 at 14:46
17

The day after lockdown measures were implemented in the UK, YouGov conducted a poll of 2788 adults testing whether they supported or opposed the imposition of the measures.

They found that 76% of respondents strongly supported the measures, 17% somewhat supported them, and only a combined 4% opposed them in any way.

Just over two weeks later, on April 9th, they conducted another poll which asked respondents whether they would support or oppose lockdown restrictions being extended further than the initial three week period.

It found that while strength of support may have dropped slightly, the public was still overwhelmingly in favour of an extended lockdown, and that any drop in support was fairly negligible - combined opposition was found to be 5%, with combined support at 91%.

Indeed, YouGov has also found that at least in one part of the UK, respondents think that the lockdown doesn't go far enough - a poll published on April 10th that surveyed adults in Wales found that a majority (53%) thought that the lockdown measures should be tightened, with only 6% thinking that the measures should be relaxed.

I think we can conclude from this that although there may be a small amount of quarantine fatigue given the slight drop in strength of support for the lockdown measures between March 24th and April 9th, the public still remains overwhelmingly content with the measures at the moment, and there is evidence that at least one constituent country of the UK may support a tightening of the lockdown measures.

Update:

Working with YouGov and ICL, the Institute of Global Health is publishing weekly international data on polling related to the COVID-19 pandemic. The full range of data is available on GitHub, but with regard to the specific question, about quarantine fatigue, the nearest question in their dataset is probably "Willingness to self-isolate", from which we can look at trend data to draw conclusions about fatigue. Similar to my previous answer, although the data from the last week in the data (Apr 13 - 19 at the time of writing) shows that some countries are clearly more willing than others to maintain isolation, there is still overwhelmingly broad support of lockdown measures. Notably China and India have lower figures, but respondents don't really go as far to say they are unwilling to stay in lockdown, rather that they are either 'somewhat willing' or 'neither willing nor unwilling' to stay in isolation.

| improve this answer | |
  • I think the answer could be quite different in southern Italy, but I only have journalistic impressions in support. It would be interesting to see some real polls from there. And of course people can support the lockdown and get mad at the lack of financial support (from the gov't) at the same time. Pitchforks was literally the name of such a movement in Italy in the aftermath of the Eurocrisis. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Italian_social_protests – SX welcomes ageist gossip Apr 10 at 15:14
  • 1
    It's also "fun" to read the predictions of UK experts about Italy, from about a month ago: reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-italy-experts/… – SX welcomes ageist gossip Apr 10 at 15:41
  • 1
    @Fizz if the lockdown is maintained peacefully for 6+ months in Italy it would be a miracle – JonathanReez Apr 10 at 16:48
  • This information, while relevant, doesn't appear to directly answer the question asked. Fatigue is only one of the reasons someone might oppose lockdown. The biggest reason for supporting or opposing it would be whether someone thinks it's necessary. If they believe it's necessary, they'll likely support it even if fatigued. – NotThatGuy Apr 11 at 22:07
  • 1
    Thanks for the update. I'll give out the bounty to this answer unless someone finds a better opinion tracker. – JonathanReez Apr 26 at 1:27
7

The University of Erfurt and the Robert Koch institute conduct a longitudinal psychological study about the perception of the pandemic called COSMO (COVID-19 Snapshot Monitoring)

From the website:

"Under the direction of Prof. Dr. Cornelia Betsch, Heisenberg Professor for Health Communication at the University of Erfurt, the Robert Koch Institute is currently operating a "COVID-19 Snapshot Monitoring" (COSMO) together with other cooperation partners. Once a week, the consortium conducts a live online survey to determine how people subjectively perceive the risks of the COVID-19 virus, which countermeasures are known, and which of these are already being used or rejected. The aim of this project is to gain a repeated insight into the "psychological situation" of the population." (Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version))

According to Der Spiegel (04/10/2020), the latest results indicate the onset of disaster fatigue in the German population.

| improve this answer | |
6

The first April poll for the ARD Deutschlandtrend in Germany shows 93% (-2%) in favor of contact restrictions, 6% (+3%) against. The questions were actually asked on March 30th and 31th, and it did not spell out against which previous poll the change was measured.

That being said, a slight drop in approval of the measures in absolute terms, but the number of those opposed doubled in relative terms.

| improve this answer | |
5

Insofar, the answer seems no, even in Italy, but the figures seem to differ substantially between pollsters; March 19:

A poll published in La Repubblica newspaper found 96 percent of all Italians viewed the closure of most business and all schools and public institutions "positively" or "very positively" and just four percent said they were opposed.

While the measures are not as extreme as those taken in China's quarantine of Wuhan's Hubei province, they still seemed unimaginable for a Western democracy until this month.

March 25:

(ANSA) - Paris, March 25 - Some 76% of the Italian population approve of the way their government is handling the coronavirus emergency. In France, this number drops to 61% and in Germany only 58% of the population approve of the measures brought in by their government, according to a survey conducted by the Kantar institute for Le Figaro.

and ... how the question is asked; on the same day:

A majority of people in both Italy and Spain (59 percent) and more than 40 percent of French people would be willing to tolerate the measures as long as deemed necessary, even if the lockdown lasts for longer than two months.

The Italy lockdown has been extended until May 3.

| improve this answer | |
3
+250

Yes, in effect. For example, the Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) has set-up a tracking poll to measure attitudes regarding the lockdown in the U.S. The latest published results (April 24, 2020) indicate for example that 14% of Americans say they cannot continue following strict social distancing for another month, along with 3% who say they can't do it at all.

KFF tracking poll figure 4

| improve this answer | |
  • Interesting. So looks like the US will hit an inflection point of 50% refusing to follow social distancing by the end of July. – JonathanReez Apr 28 at 21:51

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .